Blog Layout

How to influence positive outcomes in reentry

Robin LaBarbera • Aug 30, 2023

The art of listening.

Good conversations generate well-being, feelings of closeness, shared effort, and productivity. And difficult conversations -- when people disagree or disclose something controversial -- can produce similar positive outcomes if they happen under supportive circumstances. 


How people talk to one another (i.e., through words and tone of voice) is important in influencing conversation outcomes. But what can the listener do to shape the conversation? Quite a lot, it turns out.


It is easy to picture a good listener. This person may remain quite as their partner speaks; they might wait for the speaker to complete a sentence before contributing their own thoughts.


During the conversation, a good listener avoids looking at their phone, maintains good eye contact, and exhibits facial expressions and a body posture that conveys interest and curiosity. Therefore, the listeners’ attentional attitude creates space in the conversation for speakers to talk.


However, “high-quality” listening involves more than simply being silent and creating space. The listener has power in the conversation and can contribute verbally and non-verbally in ways that actively shape the interaction.


In this article, I will explore the meaning of “high-quality” listening from motivational, social, and psychological perspectives. Furthermore, I will argue that listening supports a speaker's basic psychological needs for autonomy and relatedness. I will also consider the implications of listening and its outcomes in the context of peer support and reentry.


You might also like this blog about peer mentoring.


High-quality listening.


High-quality listeners convey three qualities to their listeners: undivided attention, comprehension, and positive intention.


Listeners show that they are attending to the speaker through various verbal and non-verbal behaviors without interrupting them (i.e., eye contact, open posture, and facial expressions).


High-quality listeners also communicate that they comprehend what the speakers say by paraphrasing conversational content and by asking open-ended and clarifying questions. As they do this, high-quality listeners convey their positive intention by exhibiting a non-judgmental attitude toward the speakers, providing some measure of validation, and through facial expressions that convey a level of interest and curiosity.


It is worth noting that an important part of high-quality listening is that listeners must be truly genuine to be perceived as good listeners. Listening cannot be reduced to simply performing a series of techniques from an automated script; the techniques must be used with genuine interest and care for the speaking individual. Research shows that speakers are adept at detecting when listeners are non-genuine and do not respond well in such circumstances (Tyler, 2011).


Learn more about our full training on effective listening (and more) as a peer support specialist here.


High-quality listening promotes well-being.


Self-determination theory (Deci & Ryan, 2000) asserts that people have three basic psychological needs that, when satisfied, encourage motivation, psychological growth, and well-being. These needs can be supported or frustrated as a function of individuals’ social experiences (e.g., conversations). 


The first is the need for autonomy, or feeling a sense of volition in one's actions and self-expression, such that one experiences behaviors to come from within the self rather than from external forces or internally imposed judgments and pressures (Ryan, Deci, Grolnick, & La Luardia, 2006).


The second need is relatedness, which refers to feeling close or connected to others.


The third is the need for competence, which refers to feeling effective in activities and capable of pursuing and achieving meaningful goals (Deci & Ryan, 2000).


When these psychological needs are met, individuals experience well-being (Ryan & Deci, 2017), engage with others openly and non-defensively, and pursue activities with energy and perseverance.


It is easy to see how high-quality listening could be an effective strategy in the peer-support relationship in recovery and re-entry as individuals seek to rebuild their lives and make positive life choices.


High-quality listening supports reentry.


High-quality listening is crucial for understanding someone else’s perspective, involving undivided attention and asking open-ended questions. Supporting someone’s values and interests and offering a meaningful rationale also requires high-quality listening to attend to the person’s values and interests and understanding how to supply a meaningful rationale for that person. It seems then that one cannot provide proper support without listening well.


Of the three psychological needs, the most proximal and listening-specific may be autonomy, the sense of feeling make choices, freedom in self-expression, and behaving authentically in line with one’s values, beliefs, and emotions (Deci & Ryan, 2000). When individuals feel that there is high-quality listening, they feel understood and that their perspective has been taken. They are also volitional in guiding or co-guiding a conversation with their conversation partner, and they can express themselves authentically without feeling pressured or judged.


In a conversation, speakers can feel understood by sensing that their listeners attended to and comprehended the perspective, idea, or feeling they shared. This positive relational quality of caring for, valuing, or aligning with the speaker (which is likely relationship- or domain-specific) takes understanding to a deeper level to convey that the speakers, not just their views, have been understood.


Both levels (understanding the view and understanding the individual) are likely important, but feeling truly understood and validated by another may be a particularly powerful catalyst for positive experiences and behaviors.


In providing this relational climate, high-quality listening can make speakers feel safe to disclose thoughts, feelings, or personally relevant information (Castro, Kluger, & Itzchakov, 2016) that they may not otherwise reveal for fear of rejection, stigmatization, or disagreement that feels threatening.


Alongside autonomy need satisfaction, listening satisfies the need for relatedness. Speakers who feel heard feel that they are connected with their listeners, encouraged and fortified by their listeners, and have a partner in the conversation (Itzchakov et al., 2021), all of which promote relational valuing, that is, a sense of closeness and intimacy with the good listener (Deci & Ryan, 2014).


Thus, because high-quality listening fosters genuine self-disclosure and sharing in a space free from judgment, this form of listening can create an intimate, close relationship in which the speakers feel close and connected to their listeners.


Providing more direct evidence, early experimental research integrating listening and self-determination theory has found that listening promotes both autonomy and relatedness needs satisfaction. Both offer explanatory power for positive outcomes in the reentry process.


By being consistently available, providing a listening ear, and showing clients that they are worth the effort they invest, peer supporters who are high-quality listeners can be key sources of positive support for formerly incarcerated men and women.


Develop your listening skills and influence positive outcomes in reentry. Try our $25.00 self-paced, on-demand mini-course available at https://labarberalearning.talentlms.com/catalog



About LaBarbera Learning Solutions

LaBarbera Learning Solutions (LLS) is a leading independent evaluation consulting firm that partners with health, education, and human services agencies to improve lives. LLS offers consulting services and solutions that help rehabilitation and re-entry programs promote participant success, improve programs and processes, and optimize community flourishing. Learn more about our services.



References

Castro, D. R., Kluger, A. N., & Itzchakov, G. (2016). Does avoidance-attachment style attenuate the benefits of being listened to? European Journal of Social Psychology, 46, 762–775.


Deci, E. L., & Ryan, R. M. (2000). The” what” and” why” of goal pursuits: Human needs and the self-determination of behavior. Psychological Inquiry, 11(4), 227–268.


Ryan, R. M., Deci, E. L., Grolnick, W. S., & La Guardia, J. G. (2006). The significance of autonomy and autonomy support in psychological development and psychopathology. John Wiley.


Tyler, J. A. (2011). Reclaiming rare listening as a means of organizational re-enchantment. Journal of Organizational Change Management, 24(1), 143–157.


Reis, H. T., Clark, M. S., & Holmes, J. G. (2004). Perceived partner responsiveness as an organizing construct in the study of intimacy and closeness. In D. J. Mashek & A. P. Aron (Eds.), Handbook of closeness and intimacy (pp. 201–225). Lawrence Erlbaum Associates Publishers.

Scaling impact through program evaluation (credit: Shutterstock)
By Robin LaBarbera 26 Aug, 2024
You can drive greater impact with data – work with a program evaluator who has a history of publishing research in academic journals to ensure that more people set eyes on your accomplishments. We helped a client get their program expanded into 53 new locations because we published evaluation data in over 25 blogs and in three academic journals.
returning home from incarceration: improving outcomes (credit: Shutterstock)
By Robin LaBarbera 15 Jul, 2024
Based on the first round of data collection and analysis, it appears that HOM is achieving its desired outcomes. Specifically, program participants rated themselves highly in terms of their perceptions of HOM’s programs and services, ability to think adaptively under stress, psychological strength and approach to problem-solving, perceived social support, employment and educational trajectories, and positive use of leisure time.
Cognitive distortions (credit: Shutterstock)
By Dr. Robin LaBarbera 09 Jun, 2024
Cognitive distortions - irrational thoughts that can distort the way a person sees themselves, their life, their specific day-to-day situations, their relationships, and other people - can contribute to mental health conditions such as depression and anxiety. Learn how to identify and address them in our peer2peer mental health support training.
Higher education in prison (credit: Shutterstock)
By Robin LaBarbera 09 Jun, 2024
The evidence is clear: TUMI is responsible for the drastic change I observed in people like David McMillan. So, yes, we should provide educational opportunities to those who are incarcerated!
Peer-directed CBT (credit: Shutterstock)
By Dr. Robin LaBarbera 26 May, 2024
In a recent post, I explained the “why” behind the development of my peer support training program, where we expand CBT beyond the traditional therapy office to individuals who have traditionally been unable to access evidence-based mental health care. We train peer support specialists on how to recognize and address negative thought processes and behaviors and help their clients thrive. Right away, I received one very important question from a colleague on LinkedIn: Can trained peer counselors provide Cognitive Behavioral Therapy? That question deserves a thoughtful response, and I did so in this article.
CBT in peer support (Shutterstock)
By Dr. Robin LaBarbera 24 May, 2024
Some people want help with their own mental health and well-being but hesitate to see a licensed psychologist. Another group of people have the skills and want to help others achieve greater mental health and well-being, but they hesitate to undergo the lengthy schooling process necessary to become a licensed psychologist. Cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) works in a variety of situations (especially reentry), but few peer support training programs explicitly include CBT principles in their curriculum. We created a tool to train people with lived experience to implement CBT to educate clients on healthy coping strategies.
Cognitive Distortions for Peer Counselors (Shutterstock)
By Robin LaBarbera 20 May, 2024
As peer counselors, we play a vital role in supporting individuals through their emotional struggles and challenges. One common hurdle we encounter with clients is cognitive distortions—patterns of thinking that skew perceptions of reality and often lead to negative emotions and behaviors. Identifying and addressing these distortions is a crucial step in promoting mental well-being. In this article, we'll explore strategies and techniques to help clients recognize and overcome cognitive distortions effectively.
Peer Support and Self-Awareness (Shutterstock)
By Robin LaBarbera 12 Mar, 2024
Self-awareness is becoming aware of our thoughts and feelings. By understanding ourselves, we are better positioned to understand others and help them in their healing journey. As peer supporters, self-awareness is essential to preparing to encounter those we support, their families, and the system and support our peers in reentry.
writing successful grant proposals (Credit: Shutterstock)
By Robin LaBarbera 08 Jan, 2024
Grant proposals describe your organization’s mission, how you plan to use grant funds, your program's goals and objectives, a timeline for completion of the project, and an expected outcome. However, a grant proposal must be written in such a way as to convince potential funders of the value and impact of your project. At LaBarbera Learning Solutions, we’ve helped our clients write several successful grant proposals. In this guide, we’ll share with you 8 tips we’ve learned about what it takes to create a winning proposal.
belongingness behind bars (Shutterstock)
By Robin LaBarbera 17 Nov, 2023
The intricate link between belongingness and criminal behavior suggests that addressing the fundamental human need for connection can be a key element in the rehabilitation of those who are incarcerated.
More Posts
Share by: